Showing posts with label k.madhavarajan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label k.madhavarajan. Show all posts

Saturday, 27 January 2024

Summary of Oliver Goldsmith's A City Night-Piece

 

A City Night-Piece

-          Oliver Goldsmith

Introduction

Oliver Goldsmith is a poet, dramatist, essayist and a novelist.  He has contributed to English literature in all its forms.  His works are known for their observation of his society.  He explains in detail about the people and the setting of age in all his works.  A City Night-Piece is a short essay about Goldsmith’s experience during a night.  He walks alone by 2.00 a.m. and observes the people and the happenings in the streets of London.

London at 2.00 a.m.

Goldsmith comes out by 2.00 a.m. and finds the taper busy rising and falling into the socket.  The watchman is almost asleep.  People who worked hard are asleep.  People who are suffering from guilt and despair, drunkards, robbers and people who commit suicide are the ones who are awake.

Goldsmith’s Philosophical Thoughts

Goldsmith stops his observation and decides to walk around the streets.  All streets are empty without people.  A few hours before all the streets were full of people, who were very proud.  By 2.00 a.m., there are no people and no pride.  The sound of a dog and a chiming clock is heard.  All human beings are silent.  It is like a mockery of human pride.  Goldsmith thinks of a period where a future traveler like him may come and look at the empty city.  The traveler would see bushes and plants in the place of churches.  Reptiles will be seen in temples and theatres.   All places would have fallen and become empty.  The rich and influential people would become dead.  Every human being and their pride will become nothing.

The People at 2.00 a.m.

Goldsmith looks at the few people who are found in the street at that part of the day.  They are the people who wear a mask during day time.  These people will hide themselves during day.  These people are strangers, wanderers and orphans, who usually stay in the streets and before the houses of the rich.  These people horrify Goldsmith and they create pity.  Some people are without proper clothes and many are with diseases.  There are some women, who are turned to be prostitutes by rich men.  These women were beautiful once.  They were misused by villains who are rich.  These women are now suffering and shivering in snow.  The villains who ruined their life are happy and peaceful.

Conclusion

Goldsmith finds it difficult to see the suffering of all these people.  The world, for him, will give him only sufferings.  People are suffering because of the small habits of the rich people.  The powerful people destroy their life.  The poor people only cry out of pain.  Even laws become an enemy to the poor.  Goldsmith feels bad for observing such people, because it pains him.  He cannot help them and this makes him suffer more than those people.

Saturday, 9 December 2023

Summary of Bacon's Of Truth

 


Introduction

Francis Bacon is called as the father of English prose.  He was the first to write prose pieces in English, during Elizabethan period.  He writes about common topics.  He deals the topics in a straight forward manner by using less number of words.  Of Truth is one such essays, which talks in favour of truth.  Bacon argues about the values of truth.

 

Truth and Lie

Bacon begins the essay by quoting an incident, where Pilate, a Roman governor, asked what is truth but he did not wait for an answer.  People usually do not like truth because of the following reasons:

1.      Truth affects free thinking

2.      It takes a long time to prove

3.      People like lies

The philosophers who talked about truth are no more alive.  The modern philosophers who talk about truth are not that vigorous as the old philosophers.  Bacon says that lie gives pleasure in poetry, it gives gains to business men and people like it for the sake of it.  He compares truth to the day light, which shows everything as it is.  Lie is compared to a candle light, which shows and hides things.  Truth is like a peal, which shines only during day time.  Lie is like a diamond, which shines during night and changes its shade with different colours of light.  Lie adds some pleasure to our life.  Life would be dull and melancholic, when there are no false valuations, imagination and lie.

 

Qualities of Truth

People normally blame poetry because it is filled with lie.  This is not true.  Poetry is a reflection of reality.  A lie that passes over the mind is good, but the lie that sinks into the mind hurts.  Truth can be defined only by itself.  The best part of human nature is to find truth, love truth and to believe in truth.  Bacon compares truth to light through Bible.  He says that God created light on the first day and He created man on the sixth day.  After creating man, He gifted him the light of reason.  Bacon says that it is better to be present in the ship, which is in the sea and to be in the battle field and fight, than to stay in a place and look at the happenings.  Such people, who are in the field, would look and at the human errors with pity and not with pride.  Truth makes a man move in charity and this would heaven in earth.

 

Truth in Normal Life

            After talking about truth in a religious and philosophical tone, Bacon talks about the role of truth in normal life.  He compares lie mixed with truth with a gold coin mixed with copper.  The copper makes gold better, but it reduces the value of gold.  Speaking lie is like a snake that moves with its belly and not upright upon its feet.  There is not shame for a man other than speaking lie.  Bacon quotes Montaigne, who said that a man who speaks lie is brave towards God but a coward towards human beings.  By this Bacon means that a man who speaks lie will face the judgement of God.

 

Friday, 24 February 2023

Summary of Margaret Atwood's Survival

 Introduction

            Margaret Atwood is a famous Canadian writer.  She has written many novels.  The prose Survival talks about her reading habits, when she was young.  It also talks about her introduction to Canadian literature.

 

Atwood’s First Books

            At her young age, Atwood started reading Canadian literature without knowing that she is reading Canadian literature.  Later she reads comics like Captain Marvel, Plastic man and Batman.  She reads comics because her parents asked her not to read them.  She also read some animal stories.

 

Reasons for her Reading

            Nobody says her that she was reading Canadian literature.  Even if someone had said her that she was reading Canadian literature, she would not have thought much about it.  She reads for entertainment.  She did not see different literature in her reading.  She read books for entertainment. 

 

Reading at a Later Age

            Her level of reading changes when she grows up.  She reads Captain Marvel as a fantasy escape.  She reads animal stories because she finds them real.  She reads a few books on recipes.  She says that only a few recipes are good when cooked and others are bad.  The animal stories were about the struggle to survive.  It is like a riddle to her.

 

Her Christmas Gift

            When she grows up someone gives her Robert Weager and Helen James anthology Canadian Short Stories.  For the first time she reads a story named Canadian literature.  The stories have animals in the form of human beings.  The stories are about human beings chased away by other human beings.  The stories are about dead bodies.  This gives a different feel to her.

 

Conclusion

            Atwood concludes the essay by saying that she has read some her literature but other do not read their own literature.  She also says that the more she reads Canadian literature she comes to know more about her country Canada.

 

~~~~~~~

Summary of Ruskin Bond's Pret in House

 

Introduction

            Ruskin Bond was born in India for a British couple.  He was educated in India.  After completing his college he started to write stories and novels.  He has won many awards for his stories and novels.  “Pret in House” is an excerpt from Ruskin Bond’s “Ghosts of a Hill-Station”.  It introduces a mischievous ghost, Pret.  It narrates a few tricks played by Pret and how it makes the people at a home to move to another house.

Pret in the Peepal Tree

            A small boy is the narrator of the story.  He starts the story by introducing the house of Pret.  In India, prets usually live in peepal trees.  The Pret, in this story, lives in a peepal tree, which has grown in between a compound wall that divides the narrator’s house from the road.  Pret does not trouble the people inside the house because it is busy disturbing the people in the road.  It would frighten the pony pulling a cart.  It would get into the engine of a bus or car and make it breakdown.  It would knock the topis of the men.  Everyone will be confused.  Pret can be heard and felt but not seen.

Pret and Jaspal

            Jaspal is a tailor.  He stitches grandmother’s clothes.  In India people will not yawn by standing under a peepal tree.  Once Jaspal yawns under the tree without closing his mouth with his fingers.  Pret easily enters into his mouth and upsets his stomach, so that he is not able to finish his work on time. 

Pret Enters the House

            One day the PWD officers ask grandfather’s permission to cut down the peepal tree, so that they could extent the road.  Grandfather agrees to this.  The Pret loses its house.  It finds difficult to cope up with the PWD officers.  So the Pret enters the narrator’s house and gives a lot of trouble to the people inside the house.

Pret and Grandmother

            After Pret’s stay, the grandmother’s spectacles will always be found missing.  She keeps it in one place and it will be found in some other place.  One day her spectacle is seen in the nose of the stuffed wild boar hanging in the veranda wall.  Another day it is found dangling in the parrot’s cage.  Pret also cuts all the sweet peas, which are grown by the grandfather.

Pret and Aunt Minnie

            Pret disturbs Uncle Ken during his sleep by pulling away his bed sheet.  Aunt Minnie comes from Burma to stay with them.  Pret replaced her tooth paste with grandfahter’s shaving cream.  She brushes her teeth with shaving cream and her mouth foams.  One day Pret hits her hardly with grapes and she is wounded.  Pret also disturbs the young narrator by hiding his ink bottle.

Grandmother’s Decision

            The grandmother decides to vacate the house, so that they can be peaceful and happy.  They pack two carts with their households.  They also load their car and move to the new house.  As they move they hear some noise above the car.  The grandfather and others confirm that it is the voice of the Pret and it is happy to occupy their new house.

Pret’s Character

            Pret is mischievous and sadistic.  It disturbs others so that it is happy.  Pret makes fun of others by its deeds.  It can also be called as selfish.  It does not have a companion, so it disturbs and plays with everyone it sees.  As readers, we enjoy the pranks played by Pret.  Its actions are disturbing, yet enjoyed by kids and readers.

Saturday, 6 August 2022

History of Translation

 


 

            George Steiner in his work “After Babel”, divides the history of translation into four periods.  The first starts from the statements of Cicero and Horace on translation up to the publication of Alexander Tytler’s “Essay on the Principles of Translation” in 1791.  The chief features of this period is that it gave importance to empirical focus.  The statements and theories about translation were directly from practical work of translating.  The second period runs up to the publication of Larbaud’s “Sous I’invocation de Saint Jerome” in 1946.  This period is characterized by the development of vocabulary and methodology of approaching translation.  The third period begins with machine translation in the 1940s.  The theories in this period were characterized by structural linguistics and communication theory.  The fourth period starts sometime from 1960s and is based on the metaphysical inquiries into translation and interpretation.

            This division of translation is highly personal, because the first period covers a span of 1700 years while the last two cover a mere thirty years.

            Susan Bassnett divides the history of translation in the following order, which is more extensive and conducive.

 

The Romans

            Eric Jacobson claims that translation is a Roman invention.  Cicero and Horace discuss more about translation.  They say that the two main functions of the translation are much similar to the functions of a poet:  the universal human duty of acquiring and disseminating wisdom and the special art of making and shaping a poem.  The Romans were popular translators because they were less creative.  They were forced to translate so that they could create their own literature.  They believed that with translation the SL is to be imitated and not to be crushed by the too rigid application of reason.  They advocated sense for sense translation and not word for word.  The Romans translated as a part of enriching their literature than more of translation.  It is therefore believed that they had the habit of borrowing and even coining words.

 

Bible Translation

            With the spread of Christianity, translation came to acquire another role, that of disseminating the word of god.  Christianity, which is a text based religion presented the translator with a mission that encompassed both aesthetic and evangelistic criteria.

            Translation of the New Testament by St. Jerome was commissioned by Pope Damasmus in 384 A.D.  following Cicero, St. Jerome declared that he had translated sense for sense rather than word for word.  But the fine line between the stylistic license and heretical interpretation was a stumbling block in the field of translation.

            In the 17th century, Latin began to decline from the state of universal language.  Problems intensified with the growth of concepts of national cultures and reformations.  Transaltion came to be used as a weapon in religious and political conflicts.

            The first translation of the complete Bible in English was the Wycliffe Bible produced between 1380 and 1384.  This marked the start of great flowering of the English Bible translations linked to the chaging attitudes to the role of the written text in the church.

            John Wycliff was a famous theologian from Oxford.  He put forward the theory of dominion by grace, that is man is responsible to god and his law.  This theory also meant that the Bible was applicable to all human life and each man should be granted access to that crucial text in a language that he could understand.  Though Wycliff had some followers, they were denounced as ‘lollards’.  But the idea was maintained by Purvey.  Purvey revised the first edition before 1408.

            The second Wycliff Bible contains a prologue, which describes the following four stages of translation process:

1.      A collaborative effort of collecting old Bibles and glosses and establishing an authentic latin source text.

2.      A comparison of the versions

3.      Counseling with the old grammarians about hard words and complex meanings

4.      Translating as clearly as possible the sentence, that is the meaning

            Purvey too states clearly that the translator should translate after the sentence and the meaning should be plain.  He said that text must be used by laymen.  But it was said that ‘the pearl was cast before swine.’

            In the 16th century with the advent of printing the history of Bible, translation acquired new dimensions.  William Tyndale translated New Testament in 1525 and printed.  His intention was also to offer a clear version as possible to the layman.  But he was burnt alive, because he had translated the new testament from Greek and Hebrew.

            In 16th century, Bible was translated into large number of European languages.  Hebrew Bible appeared in 1488, Erasmus published first Greek New Testament in 1516 and Martin Luther published the German version in 1522.

 

Early Theorists

            With the invention of printing press in the fifteenth century serious attempts were made to formulate theory of translation.  One of the first writers to come out with translation theory is a French humanist, Etienne Dolet.  He published a short outline of translation principles in “How to translate well from one language to another”.  He established five principles for the translator:

1.      The translator must fully understand the sense and meaning the original author.

2.      The translator must have a perfect knowledge of both SL and TL.

3.      The translator should avoid word-for-word renderings.

4.      The translator should use forms of speech in common use.

5.      The translator should choose and order words appropriately.

            George Chapman while translating Homer stresses and emphasizes Dolet’s views.  Chapman states that a translator must:

·         Avoid word for word renderings

·         Attempt to reach the spirit of the original

·         Avoid over loose translations

 

The Renaissance

            Reformation was a major reason for translation during the renaissance.  During these period the translators concentrated on the affirmation of the present through the use of contemporary idiom and style.  They also frequently replace the indirect speech with that of the direct speech.  In poetry, the translations of Wyatt and Surrey led critics to describe their translations as adaptations but his is misleading.  Their translations were not faithful the roginal words but to the notion of meaning of the poem.

 

 

 

The Seventeenth Century

            In 17th century the French people were busy translating the classics.  Sir John Denham whose theory of translation was expressed in his preface to his translation of “The Destruction of Troy” covers both the formal aspect and the spirit of the work.  Denham considers the original author and the translator as equals but operating in a clearly different social and temporal contexts.  Abraham Cowley in his preface to his “Pindaique Odes” says boldly that he added and deleted words as he wished.

            John Dryden in his preface to “Ovid’s Epistles” formulates three types of translation:

§  Metaphrase – word for word translation

§  Paraphrase – sense for sense translation

§  Imitation – translator can abandon the original text as he sees it fit

            Of the three Dryden chooses the second as the best.

 

18th Century

            Dr. Johnson in his work “Life of Pope” has advocated that a translator can add something to the original work of art while translating.  This addition is possible and allowed only when it leads to the elegance of the work.  During 18th century a translator is called as a painter or imitator.  The translator has a moral duty both to the SLT and the receiver.  Goethe, an eminent scholar of the 18th century, said that every literature must pass through three phases of translation:

·         Epoch – acquaints us with foreign countries on our own terms

·         Appropriation through substitution and reproduction, where the translator absorbs the sense of a foreign work but reproduces it in his own terms

·         The highest part of translation is one which aims for perfect identity between the SL text and the TL text, and the achieving of this mode must be through the creation of a new manner which fuses the uniqueness of the original with a new form and structure.

            Alexander Fraser Tytler in his work “Principles of Translation” comes out with three principles of translation:

1.      The translation should give complete transcript of the idea of the original work.

2.      The style and manner of writing should be of the same character with that of the original.

3.      The translation should have all the ease of the original composition.

            Tytler is against Dryden’s concept of paraphrase, because it leads to loose translation.  Tytler says that a translator is a painter but he should not use the same colours of the original painter.

 

Romantic Age

            Coleridge in his “Biographia Literaria” talks about the concepts of imagination and fancy.  Though these two concepts belong to the understanding of literature it was also applied in the field of translation.  It gave rise to the problem whether translation is a creative or a mechanical process.  Friedrich Schlegal said that translation is a category of thought than something associated with language and literature.

 

Post Romanticism

            Friedrich Schleiermacher insisted in creating a new sub-language for the use in translating literature only.  D.G. Rossetti insisted in the translator’s subservience to the forms and the language of the original.  Oscar Wilde commented on William Morris’ translation of “Odyssey” and “Aeneid” as a “true work of art, a rendering not merely of language into language but of poetry into poetry.”

 

The Victorians

            The Victorians were keen on the fact that a translation need to convey the remoteness of the orginal in time and place.  Translation was considered as an activity that enriches the intellectual and cultivated reader on moral and aesthetic grounds.  Matthew Arnold in his lecture “On Translating Homer” said that a translator is a scholar and he must be evaluated by a lay reader.  Henry Wadsworth Longfellow compared a translator with a technician rather than a poet or a commentator.  Edward Fitzgerald is known for his “The Rubayat of Omar Khayyam”.  He considers the SL as a clay and a translator moulds it into the TL.  Translator is considered as a live sparrow than a stuffed eagle.  Eugene Nida advocated the spirit of exlusivism in translation.  Translator is a skillful merchant offering exotic wares to the discerning few.

 

Conclusion

            To sum up the history of translation from the age of colonial expansion to the first world war, it could be done as follows:

1)      Translation as a scholar’s activity, where the pre-eminence of the SL text is assumed de facto over any TL

2)      Translation as a means of encouraging the intelligent reader to return to the SL original

3)      Translation as a means of helping the TL reader become the equal of the original, through deliberately contrived foreignness in the TL text

4)      Translation as a means whereby the individual translator who sees himself enchanted offers his own pragmatic choice the TL reader

5)      Translation as a means through which the translator who seeks to upgrade the status fo the SL text because it is perceived as being on a lower cultural level

Translation Shift

 


 

Translation shift are some changes occurring in the translation process.  Munday, a translation theorist, considers translation as a process that involves product and process.  The product is the translated text and the process is the process of conversion from one language to another.  Shift is unavoidable in translation.  There are three kinds of shift:

Structural shift – change in the structure of a sentence when translated from one language to another.

·         Class shift – change in the word class, while translating

·         Unit shift – changing in the units of words

Popovic identifies the following shifts in translation:

1.      Constitutive shift – described as an inevitable shift that takes place as a result of differences between two languages, two poetics and two styles.

2.      Generic Shift, where the constitutive features of the text as a genre may change

3.      Individual shift, where the translator’s own style and idiolect may introduce a system of individual deviations

4.      Negative shift, where information is incorrectly translated, due to unfamiliarity with the language or structure of the original

5.      Topical shift, where topical facts of the original are altered in the translation.

Translation - Equivalence

 


            Levy, a Czech translator, considers contracting and omitting in translation as an immoral activity.  Translation is problematic and translation should find a solution not only in meaning but also in style and form.  Albrecht Newbert gives the example of Shakespeare’s sonnet “Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day?”.  Translating this line is tough for a person if his country experiences a different climatic condition.  Similarly translating the phrase “God, the father” is also equally difficult because most cultures may have a woman as their deity or God.  The problems raised while translating idioms and metaphors are called as equivalence.

            When we take an idiom like “beating the bush”, translation is not possible based on the function of the idiom.  Idioms are unique and they do not have counterparts.  Popovic identifies four types of equivalences.  They are as follows:

1.      Linguistic equivalence, where there is homogeneity on the linguistic level of both SL and TL texts, that is word for word translation.

2.      Paradigmatic equivalence, where there is equivalence of the elements of paradigmatic expressive axis, that is elements of grammar.

3.      Stylistic equivalence, where there is functional equivalence of elements in both original and translation aiming at an expressive identity with an invariant of identical meaning.

4.      Textual equivalence, where there is equivalence of the syntagmatic structuring of a text.

            Eugene Nida focuses on two types of equivalence – formal or gloss translation and dynamic equivalence.  In formal translation the focus is on the message in form and content.  Poetry is translated into poetry, sentence to sentence and concept to concept.  This allows the reader to understand the SL context.  Dynamic translation is based on the principal of ‘equivalent effect’, that is the relation between the receiver and the message should be same on the original receiver and the SL message.

            When a poem is given a set of translators to translate you will have ‘invariant core’.  They are stable, basic and constant semantic elements in the text.  Variants or transformations on the other hand changes that do not modify the core meaning but influence the expressive form.

            Neubert considers translation equivalence as a semiotic category, comprising syntactic, semantic and pragmatic component.  These components are arranged in an order that semantic is given more importance.

COMPARATIVE LITERATURE AND TRANSLATION STUDIES

 


 

            Some critics consider comparative literature as a subject and some do not consider it as a subject.  However, comparative literature depends very much on translation. Translation studies promote comparative literature.

 

            Comparative literature is a reaction against the narrow 19th century nationalism.  It is originated in France in the year 1816.  Matthew Arnold popularized the term in England in 1848, through his lectures.

 

            Comparative literature is a study of intertextuality, for example, if we have to compare an English novel with that of an Oriya novel, we have to use English or Oriya as out medium.  Certain conditions determine high translation activities.  According to Evan Zohr, translation activity takes place when the literature is in its initial stage or when it is marginal.  For example, in 12th century Europe the translation activity was significant because of a shift from epic to romance.

 

            In India there is craze for translation in recent times for two reasons:

 

1)      The writers or the critics want their literature to be translated into English or any other language because they want others to notice their literature and language.

2)      When their literature is translated there is so much scope of comparing their literature with other literary texts and its own text in source language.

 

Derrida’s theory of translation is very important.  He does not consider the source text as original because it is an elaboration of an idea, of a meaning and it in itself is a translation.   This idea about the original translation makes us conclude that translation is no more a secondary work.

 

To conclude, we could quote Susan Bassnett, who says “We should look upon translation studies as the principle discipline from now on, with comparative literature as a valued but subsidiary subject area.”

TRANSLATION AS CREATIVE WRITING

 


 

            In olden days, translation was considered as a mere rendering of SLT in TLT.  Many scholars and translators considered translation as creative process and as new writing.  Best translations are that does not read like translation at all.  Translation theories have undergone sea change with the modern critical theories.  Modern critical theories give new meaning to literature.  Based on their argument, we could easily say that translation is creative for it recreates SLT into TLT.

            A translator is a reader, an interpreter and a creator.  Sir Aurobindo says “a translator is not necessarily bound to the original he chooses; he can make his own poem out of it, if he likes…”

            Old classics, in our country, like Upanishads, Gita, Ramayana and Mahabharata have been rendered into many languages of India and the world.  Every such rendering is called as a new writing.

            K. Ayyapa Panikar says that the evolution of translation in our country began in the middle ages with the translation of Sanskrit classics like epics and puranas.  They were translated without exactness and accuracy.  These works are translated based on the features of the target language and the taste of the target readers.  The Aryan texts were translated to the Dravidian or south Indian languages, they were localized.  These localized versions are well received by the public and there is nothing alien about them.  These stand an example for the fact that translation is more of creation and not mere imitation.

            The concept of translation as a creative writing can be better understood if we examine the works of self-translators.  Self-translators are people who write the same work in two languages.  For example, Tagore’s Gitanjali in English is vastly different from his original Bengali version.  Manoj Das, a bilingual writer in Oriya and English, writes a short story in Oriya and gives sometime to translate it into English.  He keeps the plot of the story but changes many details while translating it in English.  He creates a new version in English.  Both their writings, language 1 and language 2, should be considered as new writings and creations.

Introduction to Translation Studies

 

Translation Defined

            Translation is like poetry; both are hard to be defined.  They have many definitions.  Translation is both substitution and a transference of meaning from Source Language (SL) to Target Language (TL). 

 

Oxford advanced learners dictionary defines translation as “the act of going into the meaning of a said or written word in a language.”

 

Dr. Johnson defines translation as the process of “change into another language, retaining the sense.”  A.H. Smith acknowledges and repeats Dr. Johnson’s views.  Catford defines translation from the linguistic point of view: “the replacement of textual material in SL by equivalent material in TL.”  Peter Newmark defines translation as “basic loss of meaning…between over translation and under translation.”

 

Theodore Savory defines translation as an ‘art’.  Eric Jacobson considers it as a ‘craft’ and Eugene Nida calls it as a ‘science’.  Horst Frenz goes a step further and defines translation as “neither a creative art not an imitative art, but stands somewhere between the two.”  Art is creative, craft is considered as a lower occupation and science is purely mechanical.  Translation is more than all these.  It is a process of analysis, interpretation and creation, which leads to a replacement of one set of linguistic resources and values for another.  In the process part of the original meaning is lost but an easily identifiable core is kept.”  J.C. Catford defines, “translation is an operation performed in languages: a process of substituting a text in one language for a text in another.”

 

A.K. Srivastava says, “in a translation process it is the metaphoric métier that provokes the problem of ambiguity even when assuming that the core meaning arrived at by the translation represents the temper and tone of the original faithfully.”

 

Translation theorists divide translation into two types: literary and non-literary.  In literary translation is translation of literature, wherein the rhetoric of SL should be faithfully carried over to the TL.  In literary translation, the translator decodes the motive of the text in the SL and re-encodes it in the translation.

 

A translator should be thorough with both the SL and TL.  He should ‘feel’ the languages.  He should keep in mind the socio-cultural matrix of the languages.  Meenakshi Mukerjee says, “the act of translation if voluntary, that is the material has been chosen by the translation himself and the prime mover is a compelling desire to recreate.  The translator is a writer in the language in which he is translating, that is, his handling of the language is not merely competent but creative.”

Sri Aurobindo states that “a translator is not necessarily bound to the original he chooses; he can make his own poem out of it…”

 

There is another view which looks down upon translation.  Some scholars quote the Italian proverb by Benedetto Croce – “Traddutore-traditore”, which means “A translator is a traitor” and say that translation is an untrustworthy source as it is not always genuine.  Translation has been perceived as a secondary activity, as a mechanical rather than a creative process and it does not require any extraordinary skill or talent.  It is considered more to be a grab than to be an art.

 

We cannot ignore translation for these reasons.  Translation is indeed a pipeline that connects one part of the world with another.

 

The importance of translation lies in the fact that it brings the readers, writers and critics of one nation in contact with others not only in the field of literature but in science, medicine,  philosophy, religion, politics and law.

 

Translation is as old as language and more certainly an ancient craft.  It seems to be an art as it defined by its very existence in poetics.  Translation bridges the gap between stylistics, literatures, history, linguistics, semiotics and aesthetics.

 

Translation can also be considered as a fusion of two different spheres of language which have moved closer together through the medium of the translator.  Translation studies is indeed a discipline in its own way.  It has not been fixed in a single framework to offer what the field could perform in language teaching process.  It is not merely a branch of comparative literature study and a specific area of linguistics but a vastly complex field with many far reaching ramification.

Thursday, 5 May 2022

Summary of Bertrand Russell's Knowledge and Wisdom



Introduction

Bertrand Russell is a modern philosopher, educationist and an essayist.  He was awarded Nobel Prize for literature.  He is also a famous mathematician.  In the essay, Knowledge and Wisdom, he defines and differentiates knowledge and wisdom.  He talks in detail about the need of wisdom compared with growing knowledge. 

 

Knowledge without Wisdom

Bertrand Russell begins the essay by saying that everyone should agree that human beings progressing with knowledge but there is only little growth in wisdom.  To define wisdom, we should take several factors into consideration.  The first factor is the sense of proportion.  By this Russell means that we have take into consideration all the possible factors attached to a problem.  To explain this Russell gives two examples.  The first one is during a medical research to reduce infant death rate, if we are successful in finding a medicine, it would be a trouble in over populated countries.  It would lead to starvation and low standards of living.  The second example is when we are busy with atomic research, which could also be used to destroy people.  Knowledge when used without wisdom is harmful.

 

The Need of Wisdom

Comprehensiveness with a broad mind would result in wisdom.  Knowledge is very narrow and it should be combined with wisdom, which is broad and knows about the end of human life.  This could be learnt from history.  For example Hegel gained much knowledge and came with a great philosophy.  The Germans used it to lead a war.  Hegel’s knowledge has become very narrow because it did not think about the end of human life.  It is for this reason we need wisdom.

 

Wisdom in Personal Life

Wisdom is also essential for our personal life.  It is essential for us get rid of our personal prejudices.  Though it is hard to be free from personal prejudice, one must try to achieve it.  Russell gives an ordinary example of two persons, who hate each other.  Both persons abuse each other in the same way.  They may be prejudiced.  If we have enough patience and explain them of their personal prejudices, they may become friends and lead a happy life.  This is possible because of wisdom.

 

Wisdom is Emancipation

We look at world through our senses and we are all selfish.  Russell wants us to come out of our ego.  When we are infants we give importance to our senses of hunger and cry, but as we grow we get more wisdom.  Similarly, we should grow out our ego.  This might happen when we stop thinking of here and now.

 

Russell about Wisdom

Russell says that wisdom should be one of the aims of education.  He uses the story of the Good Samaritan, who loves good and bad people.  We listen to this story in this church but we never behave like a Good Samaritan because we hate our neighbours and the people who are bad in the society.  This hatred makes us harmful.  He gives the example of Queen Elizabeth I, King Henry IV and Abraham Lincoln, who were not harmful to the people because of their wisdom.

 

Conclusion

Russell concludes the essay by saying that wisdom can be taught.  While improving our knowledge we learn about hatred and narrow-mindedness.  Knowledge must be taught along with morals, which would make us citizens of the world.  Such knowledge should be taught along with wisdom.

Thursday, 31 March 2022

Summary of A.K. Ramanujam's "A River"

  

Introduction

A.K. Ramanujam was born in Karnataka and brought up in Madras.  He is considered as one of the major modern poets of Indian poetry in English.  He has published many poems.  In almost all his poems he uses images of traditional India and places them in the modern context.  A River is one of A.K. Ramanujam’s finest poems.  It is about river Vaigai, which flows through Madurai.  Through this poem the poet talks about the old and modern Tamil poets, who have not given importance to human sufferings and emotions.

 

River during Summer Season

He begins the poem by introducing river Vaigai, which runs through Madurai, a city of temples and poets.  During summer, the river gets dry and trickles in the sand.  When all the water vanishes, the river poses straws and women’s hair clogging in the iron bars under the bridges.  The bridges are also worn out and needs mending. The river has only sand, which is like bare ribs.  There are a few wet stones, which are like sleepy crocodiles.  Apart from the stones one could see buffaloes resting in the sun.

 

Old Poets’ Observations

Ramanujam talks about the old poets, who had been in Madurai during rainy season.  They had seen river Vaigai flooded with water.  They praise the flooded water.  Their praise is all about the way the river raises by inches and how it covers the steps in the bathing place.  The poets also give a live relay, as the common people do, on how it carried away three village houses, a couple of cows named Gopi and Brinda and a pregnant woman.

 

New Poets’ Observations

            The new poets are also like the old poets.  They quote the old poets with minor changes to achieve sensation.  They say how the water level raises in the river and how it carries away a village house, a couple of cows named Gopi and Brinda and a pregnant woman probably carrying identical twins within her. 

 

A.K. Ramanujam’s Satire

            Through this poem A.K. Ramanujam satirizes on how the olden day poets and modern day poets does not view the human pain when the river dries or when the river carries their properties and people.  He comes down heavily upon the poets who are more like normal human beings and forsake to represent human emotions and troubles, which is a duty of a poet.  The poet subtly affirms the work of a poet and at the same time highlights the wrong done by the old and modern poets.

 

madhav - the author of this blog

madhav - the author of this blog
madhavarajan is here

My Blog List

Followers